Isn't the first eruption of man's fiercest sentiment the strangest thing?*
-Balzac
Allen Peniston, a most unhandsome gentleman of thirty-five, looked ashenly over at his date and then down at his ruined fish. His dining chair creaked; it was a blazingly hot July night. Peniston's awful chin, skinny mouth, bad hair, ambiguous nose, and boastful brown eyes spoiled his face with a certain inexpressive and uncomfortable sadness. The date raked her fork over five cold peas.
At a neighboring table, the end of a comment drifted by: “Of course that was before McKinley was shot.”
Windows disgorged slight breezes of cooler air, which blended with the woman’s sweet perfume.
Clearing his throat, Mr. Peniston said, “I’ll bet that McKinley did not know French. Without trying, I learned French in an afternoon.”
Silence impaled the air. Catherine Mast, Mr. Peniston's date, was a chorus girl from a popular show playing at the Casino Theatre on 39th Street and Broadway. After a reasonable pause Catherine said, “I’m not sure I understand what you are talking about.”
“You taught yourself French?” asked Dick Light, the grizzled theater producer Mr. Peniston had wrangled into attendance. (Societal expectations being what they were, it would not have been proper for Peniston to dine with Catherine alone.)
“It’s true,” replied Peniston as dispassionately as if he were dictating a telegram.
“You taught yourself French in a single afternoon?” Dick's tone was nakedly condescending. “That’s quite a feat. What does Crêpe De Chine mean?”
“It’s a fabric. I travel to Europe all the time. I’ll take you, Catherine.”
“I’ve never been to Europe,” she said in a lousy impression of excitement.
The gentle voice of Catherine asserted itself, “What is your favorite place to visit in Europe?”
“The man has the cheek to say he learned French like that.” Dick snapped his fingers. “Doesn’t that beat everything? Aren’t you curious how he did it?”
“I’m sure he did learn quickly,” suggested Catherine Mast.
Mr. Peniston became still. A moment passed. His gaze descended on his apprehensive date. “You keep looking over at that man. Is he bothering you?”
“Who?” Catherine’s voice was mollifying.
“The giant in that coat. He’s been lurking back there all evening.”
“Oh!” cried Catherine with impromptu amusement. “The telephone man. Why, he’s no bother. Really. He’s just standing there.” And with her sane and cheerful reasoning, she seemed lovelier than ever to Mr. Peniston, whose desire hissed like a kettle.
“I suppose you think he has big wrists,” was the sentence that shot from Peniston.
“Thunderingly big wrists. Is that what you’re thinking?”
“I was not thinking that.”
“I am said to have large wrists.”
Abruptly, Dick Light reached over and shook Mr. Peniston’s wrist as if it were a hand. “Catherine has an early morning. I’m afraid we have to leave.”
“You can’t leave,” he cried.
“Let’s not embarrass ourselves,” said Dick. “We agreed to a dinner. And, well, there we are.”
“Stay,” pleaded Peniston who stared at the rising figures as if dying of thirst. “The whole city knows me,” he faltered. “Walk down 38th Street. Wall Street. 5th Avenue. Ask anyone you meet; they'll know me.”
“That is enough. Take hold of yourself, Peniston. We’ll talk on Monday. Call the office.”
“This is not fair,” he cried, rage cannibalizing desire. Mr. Peniston could take no more. But what else could be done? “Not fair!” he cried again.
.
Allen Peniston, a most unhandsome gentleman of thirty-five, looked ashenly over at his date and then down at his ruined fish. His dining chair creaked; it was a blazingly hot July night. Peniston’s awful chin, skinny mouth, bad hair, ambiguous nose, and boastful brown eyes spoiled his face with a certain inexpressive and uncomfortable sadness. The date raked her fork over five cold peas.
At a neighboring table, the end of a comment drifted by: “Of course that was before McKinley was shot.”
Windows disgorged slight breezes of cooler air, which blended with the woman’s sweet perfume.
Next: an unfathomably strange occurrence. Mr. Peniston, sitting in his chair, was shaken by a difficult spasm. His back went concave and then convex. Losing consciousness, he fell from his chair. A wild culmination resulted in a medical catastrophe for the once-whole man. Without anyone applying force of any kind, a distasteful thing propelled itself through the loose trousers of Mr. Peniston (now lying facedown on the floor) and announced itself in full vulgarity. A mane of curly orange fur, salmon pink point, the galling figure mounted the tragic form of Mr. Peniston.
Locked in a fevered inertia, every person in the hotel dining room stared at the savage thing, which defiled common sense. When it spoke, some passed out.
“Hey, bub, you swell?” The thing appeared to address Dick Light.
Dick faced his table. Catherine grabbed the old theater producer’s hand and shivered.
“I'm talking to you. Hear me?”
Ice cold blood pooled in their veins.
“Respectfully . . . ” stammered Dick Light, speaking to a splash of crab mayonnaise.
“Look over here, bub. Don't you want to see someone who’s been with 178 women?”
Somewhere, the sounds of a coffee percolator, which must have started before the vile limb severed itself (if that is what happened) and stirred up wild upheaval.
“Don't believe me? Huh? First fifty were in Europe. Great bulls like you’ve never seen before in Pamplona. The plucky señoras kept passing me the wine skin, trying to get me drunk so they could have their way with me. And they did! One knew all the bullfighting moves and play-acted them out in the bedroom.”
During this unbelievably lewd interlocution, the telephone man crept up to the table of Dick Light and Catherine. Just when the truncated silhouette appeared poised to inaugurate a sequel story, the telephone man thrust the table into the air! The large raw oysters that Catherine did not care for abandoned their plate. Airborne silverware flickered. A strong disk of wood arced like the giddy jump of a dolphin, seemed to hover over the little devil, now maneuvering emphatically to escape it. With a shrill paroxysm of fear, like the squeal of a mouse, the canny member escaped the belly up table.
It climbed to the underside of the table like a predaceous creature moving combatively among enemies. This is when a large number of diners fled. The telephone man stayed, Dick and Catherine froze, and the spouses of the people who had passed out now attempted to extricate their unconscious loved ones.
Wiping his wet brow, Dick Light asked, “What do you want, sir?”
“Watch what comes outta that hole,” was the ready response. “Flipping tables onto me. You, step back.”
The telephone man stepped back.
Looking around it said, “Pommery Brut and mutton.” Amid the ruins of the happy evening, Catherine of all people hunted for champagne and meat. When she lowered the champagne flute to the floor, it consumed it greedily with a horror of slurping noises. Eventually the drink spilled into the carpet.
A plate smashed onto the floor nearby. Pointing its bullish head at the telephone man, it said, “I thought I told you . . . ” Thinking better of it, the naked creature plunged forward in the direction of the telephone man. The telephone man bolted for the back door.
More comfortably now, more in the spirit of carousing, it returned to the overturned table, “Where was I? Month later I found myself in Tangiers–watch it, fella. No sudden moves–and I wanted some fresh air. Hadn’t had peter in about six hours, so I caught a train to the Bridge of Ronda. An American traveler in Alhambra sheathed me to the hilt. Her husband, the unlucky bastard, was the commodore of the Thames Yacht Club, Sir George Lampson was his name. Without even trying I spoiled his wife.”
“God,” whispered Catherine. “This is so awful. What is happening?”
“What do you want?” asked Dick Light.
“I’ll ravish her, then,” was the response. Who it meant was of course Catherine Mast.
“Oh God,” she said. “Oh Christ. This is a dream.”
A man, nearby, watchful, placed his pipe on his table. The first blow sent the uncivil tormentor, off his perch and onto the floor. The large gentleman, a former boxer named Parker, pushed over chairs and stepped forward. The thing, floundering upon the floor, said, “Go ahead, bub.” And the gentleman kneeled and punched the head. He punched twice more in the efficient way of a boxer. It went limp but remained conscious. The gentleman picked him up in the middle and threw him on an empty table and brought his large hand down upon the base. It struggled and, remarkably, began convulsing with laughter. It was also bleeding. The man struck it again, this time with the bottom of his fist. It went still, stopped laughing. Now the man breathed heavily and said, “Will you leave now?”
“Doesn't that beat the devil,” it wheezed, oozing gore.
Catherine now held a .22 caliber double-action revolver that had apparently come from her purse. She stood and leveled it. Time accordioned. She shook. The man who had done the punching stepped backward.
The dying creature seemed only dimly aware of what was happening now. Even still it said, “I once signed up to climb Bithynian Olympus, but instead climbed an unscrupulous beauty with a foul mouth.”
The .22 caliber settled in the direction of the floor but then rose again, trained upon the thing.
“We are about fagged to death by you!” taunted Dick Light.
“Shoot the obscene wretch,” shouted the boxer. “Shoot it! Shoot it! Shoot it!”
.
Allen Peniston, a most unhandsome gentleman of thirty-five, looked ashenly over at his date and then down at his ruined fish. His dining chair creaked; it was a blazingly hot July night. Peniston's awful chin, skinny mouth, bad hair, ambiguous nose, and boastful brown eyes spoiled his face with a certain inexpressive and uncomfortable sadness. The date raked her fork over five cold peas.
At a neighboring table, the end of a comment drifted by: “Of course that was before McKinley was shot.”
Windows disgorged slight breezes of cooler air, which blended with the woman’s sweet perfume.
Clearing his throat, Mr. Peniston said, “Is everyone enjoying their meal?”
Silence impaled the air. Catherine Mast, Mr. Peniston’s date, was a chorus girl from a popular show playing at the Casino Theatre on 39th Street and Broadway. After a reasonable pause Catherine laughed, “I just thought of something from a few days ago.”
“Filmore?” asked Dick Light, chuckling.
“Yes, Filmore!” cried Catherine.
Abruptly, Dick Light reached over and patted Mr. Peniston's hand. “Gotta make a quick telephone call. Catherine, come along, won’t you.” He wiped his face with the napkin. “Stay here, Peniston.”
Mr. Peniston became still. A moment passed. His gaze lingered on the invisible trail his apprehensive date had taken to leave him. Mr. Peniston’s desire hissed like a kettle.
They were gone an unbelievable amount of time. Mr. Peniston became one with the primordial forces of the dining room.
Catherin Mast’s delicate laugh sounded once more, and his date had returned. Dick Light looked with incredulity at Peniston: “You stayed?”
“Well, I’ll be. You really stayed. You said to yourself: I’m going to do as he says and stay.”
Dick Light looked around, distractedly. “Catherine has an early morning. I’m afraid we will have to leave.”
“Call the office, we’ll talk on Monday.”
“Be careful what you say,” whispered Catherine.
“Oh right. You probably will call won’t you? No matter.”
Despite the new calmness of the dining room, there remained a fevered atmosphere inside Mr. Peniston. Raw palpitations shook his sternum. For nights afterward, his dreams were informed not by any auditory recall of the humiliating comments. He was haunted nightly by the feeling of being caged, that there was no way to give vent to the terrible, terrible agony of his desire.
*We thank the New York Review of Books (NYRB) and Peter Bush for use of this quote.